Thursday, July 14, 2016

Politix Update: Has The Elusive Hillary Clinton Been Hiding In Plain View All Along?

Hillary Clinton will be the next president less because of her many positive attributes than because her perceived crimes, imaginary as they may be, will not be enough to derail her in the Year of Herr Donald.  Talk about damning with faint praise. 
When you unpack the Himalayan-sized mountain of criticism that has accumulated in Clinton's wake since she was First Lady of Arkansas in the 1980s, what are you left with?  Let's see: There was Whitewater, a land deal in which the Clinton's had a modest investment that turned out to be no scandal at all.  There was Travelgate.  Ditto.  Monicagate.  Guilt by association.  Her vote for the Iraq War.  Which means that 373 other members of Congress should be similarly pilloried.  The Clinton Foundation.  Some smoke but no fire.  Benghazi.  Guilt by office.  And finally Emailgate.  If having a private email server and a reflexive lack of candor were indictable offenses, then Clinton should be doing time.  Along with millions of other Americans. 
Richard Cohen of the WaPo got it just about right when he wrote the other day:
"I am tempted to say that historians of the future will have to dope this all out.  But they are not up to the job.  It should go to shrinks and such, for Clinton has become a human Rorschach: Some people, particularly Republicans, look at her and see the Devil.  Their denunciations of her are so at variance with even the contested facts that it suggests a psychosis -- congressional panel after congressional panel, investigation after investigation, all of them of the kind once familiar to the good people of Salem, Mass., who knew what it was like to have the purported criminal but not, alas, the crime."
No, Clinton is not angelic, but the decades of right-wing driven blowback -- with a super-sized helping of misogyny slathered on for good measure -- have had the consequence of resulting in a couple of things this election season that piss me off even if I think our next president is a decent person. 
First of all, there is so much unfounded criticism of Clinton that it's almost impossible to criticize her at all.  Second, a cottage industry has grown up around the gauzy view that If You Knew The Hillary I Know You'd Just Love Her.   
Ezra Klein is the unapologetic water carrier for the If You Knew Her crowd, writing in Vox that:
"Why is the Hillary Clinton described to me by her staff, her colleagues, and even her foes so different from that one I see on the campaign trail?  Brilliant, funny, thoughtful, effective.  She inspires a rare loyalty in ex-staff, and an unusual protectiveness even among her foes. 
"The answers startled me in their consistency . . . Hillary Clinton, they said over and over again, listens.
"Modern presidential campaigns are built to reward people who are really, really good at talking.  So imagine what a campaign feels like if you're not entirely natural in front of big crowds.  Imagine that you are constantly compared to your husband, one of the greatest campaign orators of all time; that you've been burned again and again after saying the wrong thing in public; that you've been told for decades, that you come across as calculated and inauthentic on the stump.  What would you do?"
Klein is as thoughtful as journalists get in our bam-bam world, and he happens to be right.  The press just doesn't like listeners, and a writer for The New Yorker once criticized Clinton for "trying to elevate nodding into a kind of political philosophy."   
§  
The conventional wisdom of the moment -- reinforced by a new New York Times/CBS News poll out today that shows Clinton and Trump in a virtual tie -- is that with such high negatives, she is a seriously wounded candidate.  I disagree, because while voters distrust her, they fear Trump. 
All is fair in love, war and politics.  Or so I like to say.  But it is galling that pundits like the NYT's Maureen Dowd in particular and Bernie Sanders supporters in general have drunk the right-wing Kool Aid so willingly when it comes to Clinton.  There's gotta be something seriously wrong with her because so many people say there is, right? 
If that's what passes for logic these days, then we're in bigger trouble than I've thought.  This is because it may turn out that Hillary Clinton's greatest strengths -- an insuperable patience in riding out so many ginned-up, fact-free controversies and a willingness to listen when talk, talk, talk is expected -- have been framed as weaknesses.  And that a woman so many pundits, foes and outright enemies believe to be so elusive may have been hiding in plain view all along. 

POLITIX UPDATE IS WRITTEN BY SHAUN MULLEN, A VETERAN JOURNALIST AND BLOGGER FOR WHOM THE 2016 PRESIDENTIAL CAMPAIGN IS HIS 12th SINCE 1968.  CLICK HERE FOR AN INDEX OF PREVIOUS COLUMNS. 
© 2015-2016 SHAUN D. MULLEN.

PHOTOGRAPH BY KAINAZ AMARIA/VOX

Wednesday, July 13, 2016

Book Review: Nguyen's 'Nothing Ever Dies: Vietnam And The Memory Of War'

Every American generation, it seems, has its own war.  My grandparents had the Great War, my parents had the Good War, and I had the Vietnam War, with the Forgotten War in between.  My children had the Iraq War and, at the rate things are going, my grandchildren will inherit the War in Afghanistan, which at 15 years and counting, is far and away the U.S.'s longest overseas military adventure. 
This bloody roll call tells you a few things about America: Protestations to the contrary, we are a bellicose people who will never run out of wars because, after all, they're good for business, if not the mortality rates of young men, and remind us of how much better we are than everyone else, especially people who look and dress funny.  Wars also distract us from problems on the home front and help prime the old patriotic pump.   
The narratives we hand down about our wars invariably summon memories of heroism and sacrifice.  After the tide of public opinion turned against LBJ on Vietnam, a popular catchphrase was "Even if you don't support the war, you can support the troops," a semantic trap if ever there was one, and the narratives invariably overlook the enormous suffering of the armies and peoples of the lands we vanquish, which always is for the greater good, of course.  Our greater good.  
The Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Washington, D.C., which contains 58,000 names of American ward dead, is 150 yards long.  Do you know how long a comparable monument to Vietnamese war dead with a similar density of names would be?  (No, I didn't think you would.) 
It would be nine miles long. 
§  
Wars are fought twice over -- once on the battlefield and once in our memory -- and that is the subject of Nothing Ever Dies: Vietnam and the Memory of War, a scholarly, profound and challenging but hugely readable new book by Viet Thanh Nguyen.   
Nguyen cites the works of philosophers, historians, journalists, filmmakers and artists who have plumbed the murky depths of the psychological impact of war on combatants and civilians, but to my mind Nothing Ever Dies is nothing less than the paradigm exploration of the subject as it applies to war in general, but especially my war.   
He writes:
"The problem of war and memory is . . . first and foremost about how to remember the dead, who cannot speak for themselves.  Their unnerving silence compels the living -- tainted, perhaps by, a touch or more of survivor's guilt -- so to speak."
Nothing Ever Dies arguably is the nonfiction underpinning of his magnificent The Sympathizer, which won the 2016 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction.  (Click here for my review.)  This debut novel explores the post-Vietnam identity and politics of America through the eyes of a Vietnamese army captain and spy whose loyalties are deeply divided between East and West.   
I wrote: 
"The analogy is imperfect, but will suffice: The Sympathizer . . . is a terrific bookend to Fire In the Lake, the Frances FitzGerald classic.  While one book is fiction and the other nonfiction, both tell the story of the Vietnam War, its aftermath and legacy from a Vietnamese point of view.  And both, in their genre different but similarly powerful ways, are reminders to believers of the cocked-hat notion the U.S. could have 'won' the war if the politicians had only butted out, that it was a fool's errand from start to ignominious finish.  And while there was a surplus of fools on all sides, the biggest were the brass at the American Central Command in Saigon."
Nguyen was born in Vietnam and raised in the U.S.  He is harshly critical of American conduct in the Vietnam War and the amnesia that has conveniently enabled many of us to forget what a humbling defeat it was for our self-aggrandizing imperialist selves.  But he is no apologist for the Vietnamese, who called the decade-long conflict the American War and considered it a resounding victory, which it was not.  He writes that both countries "have not lived up to their revolutions." 
§  
In Nothing Ever Dies, Nguyen references Apocalypse Now, the epic 1979 Vietnam War film starring Marlon Brando as the insane Special Forces colonel who commands his own Montagnard troops as a sort of demi-god.  The Sympathizer has numerous indirect references to the Francis Ford Coppola masterwork, including the character of a megalomaniacal Hollywood director who hires the captain-spy to critique his war movie and share his expertise during filming in the Philippines, which happens to be where Apocalypse Now was shot.
"Apocalypse Now is an important work of art," Nguyen told an interviewer in the run-up to publication of Nothing Ever Dies, "But that doesn't mean that I'm going to bow down before it. I'm going to fight with it because it fought with me," 
Nguyen first saw Apocalypse Now when he was 10, a Vietnamese refugee who spoke fluent English, and says he was devastated.   
"People just like me were being slaughtered," Nguyen told the interviewer.  "I felt violated.  It was an antiwar movie about the war in Vietnam, but the movie was about Americans.  The Vietnamese were silent and erased."   Thus began his scholarly, decades-long pursuit of war and memory.   
He is referencing both the U.S. and Vietnam, and for that matter any other nation, when he writes:
"The problem of how to remember war is central to the identity of the nation, itself almost always founded on the violent conquest of territory and the subjugation of people.  For citizens, garlands of euphemism and a fog of glorious myth shroud this bloody past.  The battles that shaped the nation are most often remembered by the citizenry as defending the country, usually in the service of peace, justice, freedom, or other nobles ideas. Dressed in this way, the wars of the past justify the wars of the present for which the citizen is willing to fight or at least pay taxes, wave flags, cast votes, and carry forth all the duties and rituals that affirm her or his identity as being one with the nation's."
In the end, Nothing Ever Dies is a powerful meditation.  It is a book to be read in small sips and not big gulps.  It is worthwhile alone for revealing the intellectual roots of The Sympathizer, but even more so for confirming in compelling and passionate terms how we choose to remember and how we choose to forget, most notably for me that America is indeed fighting a forever War. 

Tuesday, July 12, 2016

'Well The Guy In The Five And Dime Store Said It Ain't Anywhere Around Here'


I DISCOVERED AMERICA
By Graham Parker

There was smoke up to my eyeballs
Poison burned my throat
But i said i'd keep on going
When everyone said don't
With my bony-chested t-shirt
Some stolen guitar licks
Navigating by dead reckoning
In 1976
And when the mighty chains of darkness
Had me on the ropes
Everyone said quit now
That's when I found hope

So please don't tell columbus
Don't tell his queen for sure
That i had the accurate compass
And i discovered America

Well the guy in the five and dime store
Said it ain't anywhere around here
Take your business elsewhere
Along with your mad idea
So i looked inside your closet
And your broken tv set
You said that you were born here
But you hadn't found it yet

So please don't tell columbus
Don't tell his queen for sure
That i had the accurate compass
And i discovered America

Well i knew one day she'd let me in
I knew i'd get the girl
And live in a town called veteran
Pork capitol of the world

So please don't tell columbus
Don't tell his queen for sure
That i had the accurate compass
And i discovered America

Well they've dammed the yangtse river damn it
There'll be hell to pay
But i guess that's what you do
When the yangtse river gets in your way

But i had that positive feeling
I knew i was on the right track
When a flat earth society member
Told me i must turn back
He said i'd reached the abyss
And keep on going down
So i gave him my last pencil
And i flattened him to the ground
Then an army of christian soldiers
Broke through the ranks and charged
With their ice cream vendor buddies
And their milquetoast rearguard
They had wheelbarrows full of elastic
And paper mache hearts
And thinks i did not recognize
Impaled upon their darts
And when the mighty chains of darkness
Had me on the ropes
Everyone said quit now
That's when i found hope
Yeah that's when i found hope

So please don't tell columbus
Don't tell his queen for sure
That i had the accurate compass
And i discovered America

GRAM PARKER VIDEO HERE / PHOTOGRAPH © CONWAY LINK 

Monday, July 11, 2016

2016: The Year America Had A Nervous Breakdown. From Sea To Shining Sea.

No matter what, there are bound to be big problems in a nation of 320 million people, more guns than people, an unraveling social order and a yawning gap between the rich and everyone else.  But the epidemic of deaths of minorities during routine police traffic stops, the carnage being inflicted on innocents by assault weapon-wielding crazies, the accelerating dialectic of violence and retaliation, and the emergence of a racist demagogue as the standard bearer of the Republican Party are less reminders of the frailty of a democracy that has been historically short on delivering what its leaders promise than a full-blown nervous breakdown.  From sea to shining sea. 
Let's be clear that government has not necessarily failed America, but our politicians have.  As custodians of a democracy that has effectively limited political choice to two parties, one only slightly less unsavory than the other, politicians with only the rarest of exceptions have used the powers of their office to enrich themselves and enable the special interests who bankroll them while they perpetually campaign for reelection.  It is no coincidence that in this year of our nervous breakdown, we have been gifted a Herr Donald and a She Who Wears Pants Suits, the former a consequence of a political party that has long pandered to hate mongers and the latter a reminder that the long overdue election of the first woman president may be overshadowed by her Nixonian failings. 
§  
To say the center is not holding is an understatement.  Yet 2016 is not 1968 all over again, an unfortunate comparison being bandied about with tone-deaf abandon by the punditocracy in the wake of the Orlando and Dallas massacres, as well as deaths at the hands of police officers in Baton Rouge and St. Paul, to name only the two most recent outrages.   
Yes, there were waves of violence in 1968 as exemplified by the MLK and RFK assassinations, but it also was the year Americans understood the Vietnam War for its awfulness and turned out a morally bankrupt president. The civil rights and women's movements entered the mainstream, and Republicans and Democrats actually got along.  When you consider that all those things were positive consequences of a more or less functioning democracy, 1968 actually was a pretty damned good year compared to our present dysfunction.    
There is a lot that is right about America in 2016.  This includes a two-term African-American president who has been the right leader for the times despite obdurate Republicans and the stench of racism, which had been lurking in its hidey-hole and never really went away, a fairly robust economy, a revival of the vibrant big city, significant strides toward equality for gays, and a timely reminder that despite the stop-and-frisk carnage most cops are good people doing a tough job.  But none of that really counterbalances, mitigates or nullifies the awfulness. 
In 2016, America is first among so-called developed nations by some measures, but all of them are negative.  These include infant mortality, incarceration rates, health-care costs, obesity and child poverty.  And it is last among those nations in commitment to infrastructure development, broadband access and arts funding, while millions of people struggle with crushing student loan debt as a result of outrageously expensive but mediocre college educations that did little to prepare them for the real world, only a life of gobbling anxiety-disorder medications to make it through each day.
Despite natterings to the contrary, our nervous breakdown cannot be blamed on ISIS, Brexit, Vladimir Putin, Twitter, energy drinks, rising sea levels or the war in Afghanistan, which at 15 years and counting is far and away the U.S.'s longest overseas military adventure.  
No, our breakdown is entirely self-inflicted.  And how did Congress respond to the dreadful events of last week?  It recessed and went on vacation. 
§  
As Jamelle Bouie noted in Slate, a week "that began with Americans celebrating their best qualities ended with the country staring into the eyes of its worst self," although for some people those dreadful events were less a case of the republic falling apart than waking up.   
Sorry, but I'm unable to go anywhere near there.  What is happening to America is a kind of entropy, a gradual decline into disorder.  Our selective outrage -- pretending that one person's pain is greater than another's -- makes things worse.  If you happen to be white like me, the chances of your ever being the victim of police brutality is minuscule, okay?  (By the same token, any time the Black Lives Matter folks want to dial back on their over-the-top rhetoric and recall the lessons of their civil rights forebears would be welcome.)
What then is a nation to do?  How to break the vicious cycle of violence and retaliation?  Before the gun smoke had even cleared in Dallas, I wrote that:
Prayer helps.  Dialogue is always welcome, but talk is cheap.  Nor would a white Martin Luther King whom at least some racists and gun huggers might heed begin to turn the tide.  God is going to let us work this out on our own.  That is if we don't kill each other first.  No, the short-term answer is tough, even draconian gun laws, including a ban on all assault-style weapons and severe restrictions on all other weapons. 
This, of course, is something that will never happen in a land . . . where the all-powerful National Rifle Association could care less what the motivation or skin color of the person pulling the trigger is, only that there are an ever growing number of triggers to pull.
It should be noted that the victims of the police traffic stops in Baton Rouge and St. Paul had guns, and the more people who are carrying -- yes, even legally -- the more deadly racialized poicing will become. 
There also is little guarantee that legally enforced gun sanity will matter when you have people like Dr. Ben Carson helpfully noting in the wake of Orlando and then Dallas that Americans don't have assault weapons to hunt deer, but to defend themselves against their government.  And while we're talking about disturbed black people, of which Carson certainly is one, let's understand that blacks who target whites like the Dallas sniper are little different from white people who target blacks, while for every Micah Johnson there are many clones of Dylann Roof, the Charleston church gunman, whose goal in life was to start a race war.
I continue to believe that we are so much better than ourselves.  That we can stop hating even if we can't necessarily start loving.  But Millennials, who have recently overtaken Baby Boomers like myself as America's largest group, show no indication that they're any wiser, and recovering from our national nervous breakdown, as opposed to muddling through it, seems unlikely. 


PHOTOGRAPH BY REUTERS

Sunday, July 10, 2016

Politix Update: Speculation Heats Up That Herr Donald Is Only In It For The Game

To say that this political year is different than any other has -- like so many things about this political year -- become an understatement.  The reason, of course, is Donald Trump, who while not exactly defying gravity, has done a pretty good imitation of it by being so reckless that some pundits are coming around to a point of view I first espoused way back in early March after he swept the Super Tuesday primaries.  As driven as Trump is by success and as immense as his boy-man craving for acceptance may be, he really doesn't want to be president. 
I wrote then that:
"I have had a thought bouncing around in the recesses of my mind for some time now: Trump will make some sort of grand gesture at some point because he really is not, down deep, interested in being president, and may even understand that he is incapable of being president. 
"I do not know what form that gesture would take or when he will make it, but after many months of this wild ride, I still cannot believe he's in it for the long haul." 
The wild ride has continued, of course, making Mr. Toad seem like a mere amateur.  There may be a "sort of grand gesture" in the offing and there may not, but Trump's by-now familiar pattern of blowing virtually every opportunity to make headway as he slips steadily and inexorably in the polls may in fact be a bunch of little grand gestures.   
There were three of them last week, they were whoppers, and they followed a by now familiar pattern.   
Given an opportunity made in political heaven to rake Hillary Clinton over the coals after FBI Director James Comey questioned her judgment and competence in how she handled classified emails -- a ready-made Republican attack ad if there ever was one -- Trump went way off script by asserting that she had bribed Attorney General Loretta Lynch to avoid being prosecuted.   
Given an opportunity to back away from a campaign ad showing an anti-Semitic image of a six-pointed star next to a picture of Clinton, with money raining down in the background, Trump instead offered a defiant defense ("It's just a star") and asserted in manic tones that his campaign was the victim of racial profiling. 
And given an opportunity to walk back from an extemporaneous outburst during a speech ostensibly about the economy in which he praised former Iraqi thug-in-chief Saddam Hussein for being "so good at killing," he vigorously reaffirmed his point of view and repeated that the U.S. never should have deposed him. 
(Trump did manage to stay relatively restrained after the Dallas sniper attack, although he managed to gin up some controversy after being denied a request to address a roll call at a Midtown Manhattan police precinct for the media hordes and then denying he had made the request.)
It was with the blown opportunities lurking in the background that Jason Horowitz suggested in a July 7 New York Times story that an increasing number of observers (unnamed, of course) believe that Trump keeps self immolating to generate more news coverage, never mind that it's almost always negative these days, and he may be more interested in winning the presidency than serving as president.  Bingo!   
Writes Horowitz:
"[A]s the race has turned toward the general election and a majority of polls have shown Mr. Trump trailing Mrs. Clinton, speculation has again crept into political conversations in Washington, New York and elsewhere that Mr. Trump will seek an exit strategy before the election to avoid a humiliating loss . . . one that would let him avoid the grueling job of governing, return to his business and his now permanent status as a media celebrity."
Trump, for his part, won't rule out quitting after he is elected.  Because, you know, he's gonna be elected. Presented with that scenario during a recent interview with Horowitz, Trump is said to have flashed a mischievous "you're onto something" smile, shook the reporter's hand, and said:
"I'll let you know how I feel about it after it happens."
Trump is the conspiracy freak, not me.  But I have no trouble working my fervid mind through Trump's nonstop and over-the-top aggression, seeming antipathy about campaigning in the states he needs to win, his disdain for building a serious campaign organization or raising serious scratch, and his penchant for self sabotage to a scenario where the nomination would be wrested from him at the Cleveland convention, and that would be okay. 
I'll let you know how I feel about it after it happens.


POLITIX UPDATE IS WRITTEN BY SHAUN MULLEN, A VETERAN JOURNALIST AND BLOGGER FOR WHOM THE 2016 PRESIDENTIAL CAMPAIGN IS HIS 12th SINCE 1968.  CLICK HERE FOR AN INDEX OF PREVIOUS COLUMNS. 

© 2015-2016 SHAUN D. MULLEN.
Photograph by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

Cartoon du Jour

SEAN DELONAS/CAGLECARTOONS.COM

Friday, July 08, 2016

After Dallas: 'This Is War. Watch Out Obama. Real America Is Coming After You.'

How fitting, in the grotesque sort of way that American society predictably moves from outrage to outrage and carnage to carnage through these lazy hazy summer days, that the sniper attack on Dallas police officers took place a short stroll from the most famous attack of them all. 
Texas is indeed the epicenter of all that is wrong in these gun-sick United States, but what is more important at the moment is that the sniper attack on November 22, 1963 at Dealey Plaza that snuffed out the life of John Fitzgerald Kennedy and the sniper attack last night a mere 1,000 feet away at El Centro College that snuffed out the lives of five police officers were attacks on the established order.   
Once the historic mists are parted and pet conspiracy theories put aside, and regardless of whether there was one sniper or two on that cold autumn day, the 35th president of the United States was silenced because he and his administration were a threat to the established order, most probably the epidemic of organized crime that had bestowed La Cosa Nostra and its ethnic brotherhood with the status of a powerful shadow government.  And it may turn out that while the sniper who dispatched five police officers on July 7, 2016 was a black who hated whites, and white cops in particular, he also was pushing back against the established order. 
I don't really want to go here, but here I go: 
Barack Obama has a little under 200 days to serve, and I won't begin to exhale until he is no longer our president, although he certainly will remain a Kenyan-born nigger and the Antichrist to far too many people.  You know what I'm talking about, America.   
The usual batshit crazy spokesmen for our sickest were out of their caves and howling before the gun smoke had cleared in Dallas.  Tweeted Tea Party darling and former Congressman Joe Walsh: 
This is war.  Watch out Obama.  Watch Out Black Lives Matter punks.  Real America is coming after you.
Most cops are good guys.  Most Americans mean well.  But black people are being killed by white cops at such a rate that most of these killings don't even make the national news anymore. (And if I may say so, black people don't need sympathy; they need respect.) Now police officers merely trying to make sure a peaceful protest over those killings stayed that way are being mowed down.   
The hate abroad in the land is palpable.  The dialectic of violence and retaliation is appalling.  Our selective outrage is nauseating.  Mass shootings are occurring with such numbing frequency that they have begun to seem like so many ruffled feathers, and the carnage is the only relief we're getting from a presidential campaign between a racist and a woman who ignores the legal requirements of office because they're inconvenient.  Orlando?  Isn't that where Disney World is?   
Then there are Walsh's pals, the sick Republican f*cks in the House who don't want to even minimally toughen gun laws to try to prevent terrorists from buying the killing machines that are easier to purchase than getting a driver's license, and the ever observant Dr. Ben Carson, who lit into Obama for "politicizing" the Dallas tragedy and helpfully reminded us that people need high-powered weapons not to hunt deer, but to be able to defend themselves from their government.   
Are you surprised that the Dallas perp is black?   
That the kind of befouled mental state we have come to associate with white Christianist nuts, Klans and militiamen doesn't respect racial boundaries in 2016 America? 
That despite the yammerings of xenophobic right-wingers, we yet again have another instance of homegrown terrorism?   
That the Dallas officers were shot in the back?  Videos show white, black and Hispanic cops using their bodies to protect innocents from the hail of gunfire.
It's hard to say whether we are more terrified of the police than the police are terrified of us.  Astounding.  But a solution to the never ending cycle of violence is simple.   
Prayer helps.  Dialogue always is welcome, but talk is cheap.  Nor would a white Dr. Martin Luther King to whom racists and gun huggers might listen begin to turn the tide, as some thoughtful people have suggested.  God is going to let us work this out on our own.  That is if we don't kill each other first.   No, the short-term answer is tough, even draconian gun laws, a ban on all assault-style weapons and severe restrictions on all other weapons.  This, of course, is something that will never happen in a land where the National Rifle Association long ago replaced the mob as a powerful shadow government and could care less who the person pulling the trigger is, only that there are an ever growing number of triggers to pull.   
For all the talk of ours being the greatest nation on earth, we're not even coming close anymore, folks.  As for being the sickest, we're there.

PHOTOGRAPH BY L.M. OTERO/THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

Cartoon du Jour

JEN SORENSEN

Thursday, July 07, 2016

(Part Two) Trip Of A Lifetime: South America On A Dime . . . No, Make That A Nickel!

The 15th century Incan city of Machu Pichhu was our eventual goal
By JOHN "BEET" BAILEY
A couple of days after the mudslide, we arrived in Cuzco — the gateway to Machu Picchu.  
The city (elevation 11,152 feet) was the capital of the Incan Empire.  The architecture was monolithic, but has been built over in places and sometimes looted by the Spanish conquerers.  The Incan stonework is so tight that you can’t slip a credit card into it.  And all without mortar, just extraordinarily close-fitting boulders.  The Spanish had constructed their buildings over these huge stones.  Quite a dichotomy of stonework!  
We found a very cheap ($6) room that we shared with a Colombian friend we had met while traveling.  We broke down the double mattresses beds and made four bunks, and tried to get some sleep since we had to be up early to catch the train to Machu Picchu.  The problem was the bedbugs.  We were bitten and scratched and scratched, and referring to them, I said to the Colombian, "Insectos!" No, he replied, "Animales." 
After our fitful sleep, we made it to the railroad station and boarded a second-class train to begin the 150 kilometer, four-hour journey to the mountaintop citadel.

Traveling second class meant our train had to pull onto sidings to let first-class trains chug past, and we stopped at villages where permissios would hop aboard.  These large-hipped Indian women, usually accompanied by a small child or two papoosed to their backs, would be
peddling local  foodstuffs.  "Permisio" is what they would say as they hip checked through a train car with the expertise of an NBA center, covering the entire train in the few minutes we were stopped.  
The day was sunny and the air clean, so we preferred to stand with other backpackers on the platforms between the cars instead of sitting in the dingy cars. 
Then Mother Nature called.  
I went into the rest car and sat down on the open toilet.  I looked up and noticed that the mirror and railing that ran the length of the car had small turds below them.  Then I understood.  These peasants had never seen "modern" bathrooms and they certainly weren’t going to poop in the well, like I was.  I went back and told my traveling companions, and they verified my analysis. 
We arrived at the Machu Picchu station at Aguas Calientes (elevation 6,700 feet) early in the afternoon.  
We had been forewarned by other travelers to hurry to the quonset hut shelter nearby and claim either a stick rack or hammock so we wouldn’t have to sleep on the wet floor.  (It was rainy season, remember?)  Well, I was ready.  My dad had worked on trains all his life and I sometimes traveled with him, so I had a leg up on these poor, backward people. 
The train was slowing as it rolled into the station and I was poised between cars at the steps.  Not waiting for the train to come to a complete stop, I jumped onto the cobblestoned street, my 100-pound pack on my back, and my forward momentum and high center of gravity flipped me.  I body slammed into the cobblestones!  
As I laid dazed — the wind knocked out of me — I looked up and these poor, backward people were all pointing at me.  I laughed at the foolishness of my dismount, as well.  
I picked myself up and hastened to the hut where I grabbed a bunk and started making our "bean soupa."  No mean feat because at that altitude it took a long time  to boil water.  Eventually it simmered and we shared our repast with our traveling friends.  Without insectos to bother us, we fell asleep that night to hauntingly beautiful music — Crosby, Stills and Nash and the Beatles — sung and played by some fellow travelers, Brazilians perhap, that evoked melancholy thoughts of home. 

 BREATHTAKING AND TRANSCENDENT
We were up early and began our ascent of Machu Picchu, which is at 8,920 feet.  Because of the altitude, we couldn’t handle the straight-up climb from the base camp taken by the natives who worked at Machu Picchu, so we took the circuitous, serpentine, switchback road, which took a couple of hours longer. 
Well worth it, though.  This amazing city on top of the mountain was built in 1450 or so as an estate for an Incan emperor and was abandoned in the 17th century for fear the Spanish conquerors would find it, which they never did.  It was "discovered" by American explorer Hiram Bingham in 1911.   
Machu Picchu is roughly divided into an urban sector and an agricultural sector with terraced fields.  There was an upper town with temples, including the Temple of the Sun, and homes for the emperor and upper-class people and a lower town for lower-class people.  There are about 200
buildings, many of them restored, on wide parallel terraces around a central square.  Sophisticated channeling systems provided irrigation for the fields, while stone stairways set in the walls allowed access to the different levels. 
The stonework and courtyards were phenomenal, but that wasn’t enough for the Tres Amigos and we decided to scale Huanya Picchu (elevation 9,843 feet), which looks down on Machu Picchu and was where the Incan priests had lived.  The structures there are even more massive.  
This was an ordeal.  Rough hewn cutback stone steps were the only way up.  Granted that we were young (mid-20s), but we were sea level boys and that altitude is hard to adjust to.  But the resulting view was breathtaking and the feeling transcendent.  I suppose the combination of altitude, exhaustion and lack of proper diet had us in a metaphysical state.  Definitely the most amazing place I’ve ever seen! 
After descending Huanya Picchu (photo, lower right), which was definitely easier and faster than climbing, we began the northern leg of our journey, which was down the eastern slope of the Andes toward southern Peru and by bus and train.  At one of the many towns we went through, I made the cardinal mistake of eating the local fruit, which had the same effect as drinking the water, and Montezuma’s Revenge ensued.  
I needn't tell anyone who has had Montezuma’s Revenge, but this involved severe diarrhea and/or vomiting.  I had the worst-case scenario.  Both ends!  It really hit me when I was on a crowded train on the highest rail line in the world.  I was climbing over people to get to the bathroom, and they were nearly as uncomfortable as I was. I felt -- and looked -- like death warmed over. 
After a few days, we arrived in the town of Arequipa (elevation 7,661 feet).  It was 2 in the morning.  
Nothing was open, we couldn’t find a place to sleep, and I was week from three days of sickness.  I was carrying that
100-pound backpack and finally said, "I’m sleeping here," which happened to be the carport of a car dealer.  We got a few hours of sleep before someone showed up for work and chased us away. 
It was at this point that Simon decided to return to Lima and meet us there for the trip back to the States.  Mac and I wanted to see the Plains of Nazca and the famous prehistoric lines on the way back up western Peru to Lima.  The trouble was that the Atacambe Desert stood in our way — the driest place on earth.  Even drier than the Sahara with temperatures well over 100 degrees F.   
We talked our bus driver into letting us off at Nazca.  Very interesting place, but hard to appreciate at ground level.  Lots of straight and curved lines running for miles.  After exploring the city, we found a family who let us sleep on their porch and gave us a drink of water.  We left early in the morning, and since we were near the end of our trip, we left behind our trenching tools and other unneeded items.  I wonder if they remember our visit? 
Mac and I set out hitchhiking on the Pan America Highway.  We were lucky enough to get a ride in the back of an old stake-bodied truck that let us off about three miles from Ica (elevation a mere 1,332 feet), where we were to catch another bus.  It was the middle of the day and our backpacks were still full enough to make the hike into Ica foolhardy.  We paused at the only grove of trees for miles around and started hitchhiking again.  Not much traffic and not much luck.  
We spent about three hours under a tree where I carved "Beet Was Here" with my penknife.  Mac finally couldn't take it anymore and insisted we keep hitchhiking.  It was well over 100 degrees and I tried to reason with him to wait until the sun started to go down (in only about two more hours), but he wouldn't listen.  Mac never listened.  He could be a stubborn ass. 
Mac threw his backpack on and started to walk to Ica.  We had already been separated twice before by his obstinance, and suddenly I couldn’t take it anymore!  I threw on my backpack and raced Mac to Ica, telling him along the way what I thought of him, his ancestors and his obstinance.  I had finally dissipated my anger by the time we slogged into Ica, but I still get upset thinking about it today.  Stupid that something would still bother me that much 43 years later. 
After catching the bus at Ica, Mac and I had an uneasy truce.  We arrived in Lima and met Simon at the Plaza des Armes.  We got a comfortable room for the night and looked forward to our return to the good old U.S. of A.   
We had a good time traveling, saw some amazing things and met some nice people.  But home is home and the U.S. is ours.   
When we reached Miami, Simon had to fly back to Newark to work while Mac and I met some friends in the Florida Keys and awaited the arrival of Catbird, Dr. Duck and the old Chevy wagon for the trip north.  The gas cans were still on the roof, and thinking back on it, I can't believe we weren't hassled by the police because of the obvious safety concerns.   
Looking back on our trip, I recommend traveling while you're young enough to do it.  Don't wait until your old and it seems too daunting.  And definitely visit Machu Picchu and Huanya Picchu, the neatest place I've ever been.